From Beneficiary to Economic Citizens

Client/Funder

  • CGAP

Sector

  • Finance

Services

  • Design Research
  • Services & Experiences

A study of the government-to-person (G2P) payments ecosystem, and the barriers to and enablers of financial inclusion.

The Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP) is an independent policy and research centre, housed at the World Bank, that works to advance financial access for the world’s poor. It provides market intelligence, promotes standards, develops new solutions and advises governments, microfinance providers, donors and investors.

Since 2009, CGAP has studied the link between G2P transfers and financial inclusion, with a particular focus on the long-term impact of direct electronic bank transfers on people who, until recently, had no bank account. CGAP asked Quicksand to design and conduct an ethnographic study of the people receiving these transfers: what the experience was like, and how the direct transfer of social benefits was affecting their everyday lives.

Objectives

The study’s main goal was to show what receiving G2P payments was like for people in Andhra Pradesh, India, especially in remote, tribal areas. A secondary goal was to suggest ideas for improving that experience. The study set out three areas of inquiry:

  • the experience of receiving G2P payments, and of the new technologies used to make them;
  • the experience of last-mile agents, such as bank agents and postal officers;
  • the financial needs of the poor, segmented by livelihood and social and cultural context.

Quicksand’s role

Quicksand:

  • carried out an ethnographic study of G2P digital cash transfer recipients and last-mile agents;
  • produced case studies of customer service points (CSPs) and other last-mile agents in the digital cash transfer system;
  • summarised how recipients and agents experienced the technology.

The study

The research took place over six weeks in the Mahbubnagar, East Godavari and Visakhapatnam districts of Andhra Pradesh. The sample reflected a range of village sizes, populations, distances from urban centres, sources of income and main occupations. It also covered a range of technology platforms and last-mile agents that delivered G2P benefits.

The findings pointed to four directions for improving the G2P payment system:

  • driving transparency and accountability, and giving recipients control over decisions that directly affect their wellbeing;
  • recognising the role of community agents in helping beneficiaries use the technology, and as an efficient way to deliver Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT);
  • reimagining the G2P payment account with more flexibility and features beyond paying out funds;
  • building savings systems on community trust and social cohesion.

Outcomes

The ethnographic study was part of a larger CGAP research initiative. External partners analysed the operations of service providers (banks, post offices and business correspondent agencies), and carried out a large-scale survey to measure the impact of electronic benefit transfers on people’s lives.

Quicksand presented its findings and opportunities for advancing financial inclusion through the G2P system to CGAP and other stakeholders. These included the Department of Rural Development, the Society for Elimination of Rural Poverty (SERP), and the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI). The findings were also published as a set of printed reports, linked below.

Related

DiFi for All

Understanding digital financial onboarding experiences of unbanked and underbanked